There are five main bicycle insurance options in the UK worth comparing: Laka, Bikmo, PedalSure, Yellow Jersey, and BackPedal. They split into three categories.
Traditional payout insurers (Bikmo, PedalSure, Yellow Jersey) — pay premiums, claim when a bike's stolen, receive a payout. Differences are mostly UX, price, and claims-handling speed. Yellow Jersey adds broader cycling cover (race, travel, event).
Community pool (Laka) — members contribute to a shared pot, no excess, payouts come from the pool. Strong community focus; well-suited to cyclists who like the model.
Recovery-first (BackPedal) — a 24/7 recovery team retrieves the bike when it's stolen; the Sundays-backed insurance steps in only if recovery fails. Different product solving the same problem differently.
Trustpilot ratings as at August 2026: Laka 4.5 from 1,009 reviews, PedalSure 4.4 from 1,463, Yellow Jersey 4.0 from 308, Bikmo 3.8 from 481, and BackPedal 4.7 from 35.